Happy Noirvember, fellow film noir enthusiasts!
I had someone ask me recently (in real life, not online) why and how I, as a Christian, can love the film noir genre. They themselves have not watched much noir, but they did have a basic understanding of it: that it explores the dark side of society. Noir is full of the back alleys and mean streets where bad things happen. Why would I, as a Christian, want to watch movies that are about bad people doing bad things?
It's a valid question, and I decided to explore it.
| Humphrey Bogart and Lauren Bacall, The Big Sleep (1946) |
So I thought about it for a while, and I think that the reason I love noir is that no other film genre depicts so clearly that "all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God" (Romans 3:23) and that "the wages of sin is death" (Romans 6:23). Westerns hit on that second one a lot, too -- and so do action movies and mysteries. But they tend to have a hero/heroine who is a pretty good guy/girl overall. Not noir, not always.
In film noir, for every good cop who marries the wrong woman, ala Crime of Passion (1956), you have a "good" cop who digs himself deeper and deeper into trouble while trying to cover up a sin, ala Where the Sidewalk Ends (1950). For every sweet wife who married the wrong guy, ala The Blue Dahlia (1946), you have the "sweet" wife who is deeply involved in a number of crimes, ala Murder, My Sweet (1944). You quickly learn, while watching noir, that anyone is capable of anything. We are all born sinful, and we all teeter on the edge of embracing our sinful desires, every day.
| Alan Ladd, The Blue Dahlia (1946) |
Film noir tends not to show any solution for this other than "trying really hard to be a good person," so they are basically all Law and no Gospel. But I don't watch movies to learn about my Savior, I watch them to learn about my fellow humans. Modern movies tend to be very humanistic, touting the idea that "all people are born basically good and get corrupted by what happens to them." Which is hogwash, according to the Bible.
It's also hogwash according to film noir. Nobody has to teach the characters in noir to be bad. Nobody has to try hard to become bad. All they have to do is stop fighting NOT to be bad. Every Walter Neff (Double Indemnity, 1944) has a chance to walk away from that ankle bracelet dangled in front of them, and it's his fault and his alone if he walks toward it instead. Every Frank Bigelow (D.O.A., 1949) has a chance to stay in his room, stay sober, stay faithful to his fiancée, and it's no one else's fault if he decides not to do any of those.
![]() |
| Russell Crowe, L. A. Confidential (1997) |
Even much of neo-noir confirms this. From the absolute absence of truly good and morally upright cops in L. A Confidential (1997) to the endless lies coming from every mouth in The Usual Suspects (1995), they continually showcase the Biblical truth that "I was sinful from birth, sinful from the time my mother conceived me" (Psalm 51:5).
The tricky part of enjoying film noir as a Christian is figuring out how to learn the right lessons from it. Because noir makes every brand of sin look awfully fun. This is part of why I tend to stick to the classic noir of the 1940s and 1950s, because they will imply but not show a great deal of that, which makes it easier to avoid falling into sins like lust or condoning sinful behavior while watching them. And that's something that is up to each individual's own conscience -- one person can watch things and be unaffected that could seriously harm another person, so you have to figure out for yourself what lines you need to draw for what you watch. But that doesn't only apply to film noir, it's an issue for all movies, TV shows, and books.
This has been my second contribution to Back in Black: Another Film Noir Blogathon. Be sure to check out all the great entries!



Life is full of bad people doing bad things. So is the Bible. Ignoring any aspect of human behavior is the same as ignoring history. It makes you doomed to repeat it.
ReplyDeleteJ-Dub, so true. I think we can learn a lot from seeing the consequences of breaking laws and behaving badly played out in fiction, as opposed as to experiencing themselves. It's important to remember to be "wise as serpents, yet as innocent as doves," which I think means to be aware of bad people and the bad things they do, without participating ourselves or pruriently relishing watching or reading about their precise behavior. It's tricky!
DeleteNever thought of it in those terms. Karen is a pretty devout Christian, but I can get her to watch some noir with me. Only because of the actors, not because of the content, however, so I guess it's a little different. Not sure what she gets out of the story. Because if I tried to get her to watch a neo-noir, she wouldn't do it. It's the attraction of seeing MacMurray or Burr or Ladd, even if they are playing against what she sees as "type".
ReplyDeleteQuiggy, I think neo-noir is harder for me simply because modern Hollywood does often try to glorify wrong or even rub our noses in sin. I'm a lot choosier about what neo-noir I'll watch (and most of it, I don't feel drawn to see more than once), whereas classic noir, I'll try anything because I know it's not going to drag me personally through the mud, even if the characters are slogging around in it ;-)
DeleteBUT I definitely tend to want to always gravitate to movies because of who is in them, so I'm more likely to watch noir if it stars Ladd, Andrews, Bogart, Lancaster, or now Hayden...
What an interesting take on being a fan of film noir. When I took a film noir class online (partly via TCM, back when they still had the discussion lists), we were asked to try and define film noir. I always thought, and still do, that film noir shows you what *not* to do. Same perspective as the ten commandments, n'est-ce pas? And film noir shows examples of the consequences, which are not pretty. But I also began to see that so much of noir embraces the cause(s) of social justice, which is still a relevant theme, for example, for the Catholic Church. Lots to think about here. Thanks for a great post!
ReplyDeleteMarianne, oh, I remember those TCM classes! I took one once! Or, part of one, anyway.
DeleteYou're absolutely right that film noir shows us endless examples of what not to do. Of how even "innocuous" bad behavior can be damaging.
And yes, it definitely showcases a lot of society's ills of all sorts, including the harmful effects of even the most casual racism, ableism, sexism, classism, and so on. And the power of forgiveness and grace are sometimes showcased as well.
Glad you got some good stuff to think about from my post :-)
Nicely written post! I've always thought film noir operates on much the same wavelength as the Bible, in that it often warns us about the consequences of making the wrong moral choices. So, in a strange way, I think noir films can be good for teenagers. They teach a pretty important lesson early on: doing the wrong thing in life can have serious consequences.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Maniac! I agree that it has a lot of great warnings against making wrong choices. And if you can learn from someone else's mistakes, rather than making those mistakes yourself, that is wonderful! I like your take on noir being good for teens -- that's a great insight. These movies are especially good at showing how important it is to be very careful who you trust, which is so vital for teens.
DeleteI really enjoyed this thoughtful essay, Rachel.
ReplyDeleteLaura, I'm so glad you did! :-)
DeleteI don't think a Christian viewer needs to have any religious qualms or misgivings about watching Noir. Faith and Noir do not necessarily stand in conflict with each other.
ReplyDeleteIn classic Noir evil is in general not glorified, as opposed to Neo-Noir as you quite rightly said. The Code made sure that the bad guy or girl was punished in the end. Joe Breen saw to that. Their bad deeds were rarely ever applauded though of course they were usually entertaining to watch.
I like to see Noir, among many other things, as a morality play.
Most importantly though, one of Noir's most significant themes - which pops up in so many films - is redemption, a Christian concept if there ever was one.
Just to name a few: Tomorrow is Another Day, The Dark Corner, Dark City, Pickup on South Street, The Underworld Story, Fallen Angel, On Dangerous Grounds, Kiss of Death.
Noir is not just about a white knuckle ride to oblivion. Many of the great Noir protagonists do find a kind of salvation, although sometimes only in death. Because they finally do the right thing in the end. They do have a conscience though it was mainly anesthetized throughout the movie. But a conscience can be (re)awakened and atonement is possible (Out of the Past, Raw Deal, The Killers, Postman Rings Twice, This Gun For Hire, Act of Violence).
So there's no reason why you shouldn't enjoy Noir. :)
This is Margot. I forgot to sign in.
DeleteMargot, yup, there's a lot of the morality play in noir. Which someone who has only heard of it as "movies about bad people doing bad things" can't understand.
DeleteAnd I LOVE the theme of redemption and renewal. Which definitely is present in a lot of film noir.
What a thoughtful post. I’m a Christian, and also drawn to Film Noir. One of the core truths of Christianity is that all of us are born into a fallen world with a sin nature. So many of the characters in Film Noir know exactly who they are, and don’t put up a facade of ‘being good’, and the films more often than not capture the brokenness of the world. It just rings true. Christianity teaches that we are incapable of fixing ourselves, but reveals the solution.
DeleteThanks! I'm glad it resonated with you. You're right -- there are many noir characters pretending to be good when they're rotten, but there are also sooooo many who have no illusions about the fact that they're not good people. Much more realistic, and in line with biblical teaching, than many (most) modern movies.
DeleteAs you say, only Christianity reveals the solution. What a difference that makes in real life!